Who Owns a Valley? Law, Memory and the People Left Off the Map
From a distance, it looks like any other valley. A long green bowl, flanked by hills, stitched with paths that do not show up on official maps. In Sheldon Greene’s novels, such valleys are never just scenery. They are arguments. In Tamar , the Binyan valley holds a mixed Jewish and Native American community in the nineteenth-century American West. It is cultivated and remembered. Orchards are tended, water is diverted, homes are built and rebuilt. Festivals return with the seasons. The dead are buried in the valley’s hills, in places everyone in the community can locate by feel. For Tamar and her people, the valley is not “land” in the abstract. It is the place where their history has taken root. In After the Parch , the Glade is a forested bowl tucked inside a future California Republic damaged by drought, epidemic and political fracture. Forty families live there as deliberate outlaws, living around an old mine and growing food according to rules they have worked out for t...